Track your comments!
[x]


When you register, comments on your articles and replies to your comments appear here. Register Now!

Sign in to your account
[x]

Not a Scientific Blogging member yet?

Register Now for a Free Scientificblogging.com Account

  • Customize your profile with pictures, banner, a blogroll and more.
  • Leave comments on articles, add other members to your friend lists, chat with people on the site.
  • Write blog posts that can be seen by hundreds of thousands of readers.

It's free and it only takes a minute!

Already a Scientific Blogging member?

Sign In Now

Banner
By Barry Leiba | November 4th 2009 09:20 AM | 7 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
.

More Staring At Empty Pages articles

All

About Barry Leiba

I’m a computer software researcher, and I'm currently working independently on Internet Messaging Technology. I retired at the end of February... Full Bio

When I was a child I would watch anything to do with science fiction. I don’t now, but, well, I still lean in that direction. I watch very little major-network television, and don’t really want to get hooked on a new series, but if it’s science fiction, I’m more likely to give it a try.

In that vein, I tuned in last night to the pilot of a new series on ABC, called “V”. The V stands for “visitors”, and the show opens, after a few minutes of introducing major characters, with the arrival of spaceships hovering over major world cities. After some initial panic, the apparent leader of the Vs, who is in the spaceship that’s over New York City[1], projects her image worldwide and reassures everyone that it’s a peaceful visit. They’re thrilled to find intelligent life, they want to share with us while they refuel and do some maintenance, and then they’ll be on their way.

As a pilot episode needs to do, this one set up main characters, the story’s premise, some conflicts, and a couple of plot threads that will continue as the series progresses. I actually quite liked it, both for the story and for the way it was presented. The spaceships arrive with terrible rumbling and shaking, which gets people in something of a panic. But for our first visual glimpse, director Yves Simoneau, the Canadian who also directed the pilot of The 4400, gives us images reflected in the glass of the buildings, before showing us the ships directly. The effect works well.

I also liked that once the Vs have started having meetings with Earth’s world leaders, they set up tours of their spaceships for the people of Earth. “Yes,” I said when I saw that, “Isn’t that just what friendly visitors would do, if they could?” I thought back to when I would give tours of the computer center to grade-school students, when no one their age had ever seen a computer face to face before.

So I’m going to continue watching the series, at least for now, and we’ll see whether it lasts, and whether it continues to be interesting. It’s often disappointing when a new series like this either loses its edge after a few episodes or, perhaps worse, stays sharp but gets cancelled anyway.[2]

Here’s one thing the pilot episode made me think about:

When the spaceship is hovering over New York City, just before Anna’s soothing image is projected, something on the ship opens up. Most people who are watching it at that point start running away in panic. And I wondered what I would do. If there were an alien spaceship sitting there in front of me — not some fuzzy-blob “UFO” that’s most likely a reflection or some such, but a real, incontrovertible space ship, as in V or The Day the Earth Stood Still — would I be interested enough to check it out, or would I keep away, afraid of what might come out and what its intentions might be?

I have to think I’d stay and check it out, and I’d be eager, when it started to open, to see what was inside. I’d imagine that beings who figured out how to get here from some impossibly distant world would not have come here to kill us. I would want to be among the first to say hello.  There's the scientist in me.



[1] It always seems to work that way: if alien ships appear all over the world, the flagship is always at New York or Washington. A little U.S.-centric, are we?

[2] The short-lived Journeyman was a recent one in the second category. I liked it, and was enjoying discovering things as the protagonist did, when it was cancelled right in the middle of it all. The series only lasted 13 episodes (and you can see all of them on Hulu).


Comments

Hank's picture
I liked that leftwing atheists found a way to make V about religious cults and Republicans found a way to make it about Obama cults - even having the gushing reporter telling the other reporters to show respect to the attractive voice of hope and noting that the aliens are offering 'universal' health care (both a pun and literally).

When everyone has found a way to ridicule groups they despise in a show, that's usually a pretty good sign.

barryleiba's picture
He-he... yes.

I'm always amused at the way many people seem to need to overcategorize things.  I referred to The 4400: I liked that series, and was disappointed that it was cancelled before its story played out.  But I'm a leftwing atheist, and the story was very clearly a Jesus tale, complete with a charismatic leader who was killed and came back to life as a bearded saviour, leading an underground cult.  And you know what?: I don't care.  It was a good story.  Go with the story.  One doesn't have to agree with the author's religion, politics, or socio-economic leanings in order to like the story.

I don't have much use for summary dismissal of a story because one thinks it disagrees with one in some way.  People need to stray out of their comfort zones a bit more.

Gerhard Adam's picture
...I’d imagine that beings who figured out how to get here from some impossibly distant world would not have come here to kill us.

Funny, but I have the opposite view.  Using a similar but quite different image, at the end of the movie, Apocalypto, the key character is saved by the unlikely presence of Spanish sailing ships.  In effect, it reminds me of the same situation described in "V".  Unfortunately, we know how that turned out for the people being "visited".

barryleiba's picture
I thought about that very thing when I wrote that line — not the movie, but the situation, and others like it.  And my thoughts were that as we learn to travel further, our society develops over that time.  When we learned to cross the ocean, we were still at a too-early stage in that development.  Now, as we're just beginning to cross the shortest stretches of outer space, we're much less into colonization, no longer conquistadores.  We don't find new peoples and immediately set out to kill them and take their gold.

To be sure, we are still colonists to some extent, and we do still wage wars involving territory, resources, and ideology.  But we also have a long way to go and a lot of societal development as we go there, before we get to crossing hundreds of light years, or thousands, or more.

Of course, I'm presupposing that other societies would develop in a similar way, and it's certainly possible that an alien society could learn to travel through space and want to conquer everything along the way.  I'm just guessing not.

Gerhard Adam's picture
That's an interesting comment, but other than the bit about being lost, I don't believe that the early explorers had conquest in mind.  In fact, it was precisely the conflict between their motivations and those of the people they encountered that ultimately lead to conquest of a kind.

Throughout the history of North America, there are countless examples of how we entered treaties and negotiated terms that were ultimately in conflict with the reality of the people on the ground. 

In my view, the problem wasn't one of conquest, but rather that we never considered that those we were dealing with were our equals.  As a result, every action we took was to advance our own interests which resulted in conquest despite our lack of intent to do so.  So, it would be difficult to imagine a visitor that is significantly more technically advanced that would consider us equals ... hence my pessimism.

barryleiba's picture
Ah, OK... but we're arguing short-term vs long-term here.

You're suggesting that our history tells us that alien visitors wouldn't really have our best interests in mind, and we shouldn't trust them in the long term.

I'm saying that they probably don't mean to kill or harm us outright, so there's no reason to run away when the spaceship opens.

We might both be right, perhaps.

aliens would probably monitor our broadcasts and so know that New York would be the place to go - the UN after all.

Plus, I expect that aliens would also have a sense of humour and want to put the boots to the ID/Creationists, which are largely concentrated in the US.

but, the reality is that a country makes movies set in their own country (even when filmed in Canada, they are still set in the US) - so Americans would be less likely to tune in if the V's main ship was over Hong Kong

so far, it sounds pretty much like the original series,l sans big hair and big shouldered uniforms

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <sup> <sub> <a> <em> <strong> <center> <cite> <code> <TH><ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p> <blockquote> <strike> <object> <param> <embed> <del> <pre> <b> <i> <table> <tbody> <div> <tr> <td> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <iframe>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
CAPTCHA
If you register, you will never be bothered to prove you are human again. And you get a real editor toolbar to use instead of this HTML thing that wards off spam bots.