Track your comments!
[x]


When you register, comments on your articles and replies to your comments appear here. Register Now!

Sign in to your account
[x]

Not a Scientific Blogging member yet?

Register Now for a Free Scientificblogging.com Account

  • Customize your profile with pictures, banner, a blogroll and more.
  • Leave comments on articles, add other members to your friend lists, chat with people on the site.
  • Write blog posts that can be seen by hundreds of thousands of readers.

It's free and it only takes a minute!

Already a Scientific Blogging member?

Sign In Now

Banner
By Danna Staaf | November 2nd 2009 07:53 PM | 8 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
.

More Squid A Day articles

All

About Danna Staaf

Cephalopods have been rocking my world since I was in grade school. Now I'm a graduate student at Stanford University's Hopkins Marine Station, where I study the development and dispersal of Humboldt... Full Bio

This post is not even remotely about a cephalopod, but because I mentioned polyps yesterday I feel justified in discussing a cnidarian. Besides, these headlines really got me steamed, and what better place to vent than a blog?

Enormous Jellyfish Sink Japanese Fishing Boat (Fox News)
Japanese fishing trawler sunk by giant jellyfish (Telegraph)

In the text of the articles we read that Nomura's jellyfish is "an authentic horror of the deep that's been assaulting Japan" and has now "brought down" a 10-ton fishing trawler.

Are you kidding me? How can a jellyfish, no matter how giant, sink a boat? They cannot jump on deck. They cannot grab the boat or pull it under. Jellies are the laziest of predators: they drift through the water, waiting for prey to get tangled in their tentacles, then slowly reel it in and digest it. All of this happens entirely underwater. It is conceivable that a submarine could get tangled in a jelly's tentacles (though it wouldn't notice unless they clogged the motors). But there is no possible way that a boat, floating on the surface, could ever run afoul of a jellyfish. So what happened here?
The trawler, the Diasan Shinsho-maru, capsized off Chiba as its three-man crew was trying to haul in a net containing dozens of huge Nomura's jellyfish.

So, the crew capsized their own ship by trying to pull in a net full of jellyfish. Nice. How exactly are the jellies the agents here? How are they "sinking", "assaulting", or "bringing down" anything?

The three crew members fell off their ship after capsizing it, but were rescued by a nearby trawler. So they're fine. The jellies, on the other hand, are probably still tangled in that abandoned net, dying if they aren't dead already. Sure, they don't have the most sophisticated nervous system, so it may be hard to summon much empathy for them, but still. The whole experience is a bigger tragedy for them than it is for the boat.

To summarize, in pictures. This is a sea monter legitimately (though ficitonally) sinking a boat:



This, on the other hand, is more similar to what happens when you try to pull a net full of very big jellies on board:



Comments

But "stupid fisherman sink own boat" isn't nearly as snappy a headline.

Fossil Huntress's picture
Great piece, Danna... as a blog or an article. And +++ Noadi. Going to re-post to Twitter under the revised title.

Danna Staaf's picture
Thanks muchly! I do like Noadi's headline. =)

antunes's picture
Danna, you have _got_ to start writing these as articles!  I missed the blog post because they expire so quickly, and just read the lively discussion on /., so naturally I went looking up my favorite zoologist to see if you'd commented yet.

:)
Alex, the Daytime Astronomer


Danna Staaf's picture
Eek! Thanks for the reminder. I got in the blog habit and keep forgetting that I can write articles now.

Is there ever a reason to do a blog instead of an article?

And ooh. That IS a lively discussion! Thanks. =)


antunes's picture
Is there ever a reason to do a blog instead of an article?

I do blogs for fluff stuff, like webtoon links I want to share, or short speculative questions that are similar to what I might put in a Facebook post.  For an article, I force myself to have a) a point and b) a beginning, middle, and end.

That's just me, though.

Alex


Hank's picture
Sometimes one of the moderators will convert it to an article.  Blogs are usually short or not necessarily science and articles have a minimum length.  So if you are talking about politics or where you come down on the whole Wilco/Son Volt(*) debate ... that's a blog.   If it's a longish enough science piece like this, it's an article or blog, your choice.

(*)  Correct answer: Son Volt

Danna Staaf's picture
Got it. Thank you both!

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <sup> <sub> <a> <em> <strong> <center> <cite> <code> <TH><ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p> <blockquote> <strike> <object> <param> <embed> <del> <pre> <b> <i> <table> <tbody> <div> <tr> <td> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <iframe>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
CAPTCHA
If you register, you will never be bothered to prove you are human again. And you get a real editor toolbar to use instead of this HTML thing that wards off spam bots.