hit tracker
Physical Sciences Earth Sciences Biology Front Page Medicine Neurosciences Culture

User login

Columnists

Banner

How Could We Be This Wrong about Medicine?

User picture for Seth Roberts

About Seth Roberts

I am a professor of psychology at UC Berkeley and author of The Shangri-La Diet. My expertise is in self-experimentation; one of my papers about that is Self-experimentation as a source of new ideas:Ten examples about sleep, mood, health, and weight. I also have a personal blog here .
Seth Roberts

Medicine

Robin Hanson’s excellent essay in Cato Unbound is a proposal to cut medical spending in half. The evidence suggests that this would do little harm and it would help us focus on more helpful activities. I like the way this article summarizes the RAND experiment, searches for the right metaphor, and answers objections.

One question Robin answers is “How could we be this wrong about medicine?” My answer is different than Robin’s. I point to the way many scholarly and scientific disciplines start off useful and become useless. In the case of medicine, the lack of benefit is easier to measure. Try measuring the value of a class in 18th Century English Literature.

Technorati Tags:

Robin Hanson follow-up.

Robin Hanson follow-up. Maybe you should post up the 'become useless ' article too, so people know what you mean? I know it's easier to throw up a link but we're often the sole source for people so they don't pass through much.

Anyway, the article by Hanson was pretty good but I wonder about the convergence issue. Like any equation with multiple variables, you can't really solve it, you can only continue to converge on the best answer by spending more time. Cutting spending in half may be unattainable because the effort would be more expensive than the gains, but I bet 10-15% would be pretty easy with no decrease in quality.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
BoldItalicLinkQuote
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote> <sub> <sup><iframe><img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
More information about formatting options Captcha Image: you will need to recognize the text in it.
Please type in the letters/numbers that are shown in the image above.

Category Feeds

Science Jobs

Books By Writers Here

Internships

We do offer unpaid internships in programming and science journalism to college students or recent graduates seeking to build up their portfolios.

Development interns will need to be proficient in PHP and CSS and provide samples of work done in a multi-user environment platform and sign a non-disclosure agreement.

Science journalists will need to provide samples from a university newspaper or professional publication and list which semester they want to work.

Please use the contact info available in the footer of the page.