Track your comments!
[x]


When you register, comments on your articles and replies to your comments appear here. Register Now!

Sign in to your account
[x]

Not a Scientific Blogging member yet?

Register Now for a Free Scientificblogging.com Account

  • Customize your profile with pictures, banner, a blogroll and more.
  • Leave comments on articles, add other members to your friend lists, chat with people on the site.
  • Write blog posts that can be seen by hundreds of thousands of readers.

It's free and it only takes a minute!

Already a Scientific Blogging member?

Sign In Now

Banner
By Josh Witten | June 24th 2009 12:45 AM | 1 comment | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
.

More Rugbyologist articles

All

About Josh Witten

100% of this the rugbyologist's revenue is donated to Doctors Without Borders (Medecins Sans Frontieres). A click on one of my articles is a click that helps bring high quality medical care to the... Full Bio


Over at his blog NeuroLogica, the prolific neurologist (get it?  GET IT?) and oligarch of the Skeptic Movement Steven Novella has penned a fascinating history of the pseudoscience of phrenology - you know the one where they tell you that you are going to be an axe murderer from the bumps on your head.  Personally, noe of the many bumps on this rugbyologist's head are the result of internal pressure from my brain.  Instead, they come from large men trying to violently knock me off my feet.

Not only does Steve have expertise in the function of the brain,but he also writes a snappy conclusion (but read the whole thing first people):

Phrenology is certainly an interesting notion from a historical
point of view. It emerged out of a largely correct view of
neuroanatomy, but then became rooted in clinical practice even while
continued progress in neuroscience was rendering it obsolete. Its
originator - Gall - combined legitimate basic science with hopelessly
naive clinical claims. He can hardly be blamed, as clinical science had
not yet been developed and accepted.

Phrenology persisted long past the time that it had been rejected by
the scientific mainstream, as practitioners were reluctant to abandon a
lucrative procedure, but eventually science won out. By that time it
had evolved into just another manifestation of divination through cold
reading, and so it is no surprise that it survives as just that



I love the use of the subtly disparaging term "notion".  Well played, Steve.  Well played.


Comments

Fossil Huntress's picture


It was phrenology we can credit with the original grave robbers pricing the skulls and brains of women and men. Men's, of course, fetched a good deal more...

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <sup> <sub> <a> <em> <strong> <center> <cite> <code> <TH><ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p> <blockquote> <strike> <object> <param> <embed> <del> <pre> <b> <i> <table> <tbody> <div> <tr> <td> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <iframe>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
CAPTCHA
If you register, you will never be bothered to prove you are human again. And you get a real editor toolbar to use instead of this HTML thing that wards off spam bots.