Track your comments!
[x]


When you register, comments on your articles and replies to your comments appear here. Register Now!

Sign in to your account
[x]

Not a Scientific Blogging member yet?

Register Now for a Free Scientificblogging.com Account

  • Customize your profile with pictures, banner, a blogroll and more.
  • Leave comments on articles, add other members to your friend lists, chat with people on the site.
  • Write blog posts that can be seen by hundreds of thousands of readers.

It's free and it only takes a minute!

Already a Scientific Blogging member?

Sign In Now

Banner
By Hontas Farmer | October 16th 2009 04:27 PM | 10 comments | Print | E-mail | Track Comments
The "unusual", "eccentric", extraordinary Heene family.  It seems clear to me that these people have been through 24 hours of hell thanks to the cynical media.  Watching them on TV I ask myself, how would one raise children who you would be interested in science?  I think of my own family, and the families of many other scientist I have known, and heard of.  For the record I don't think this was a hoax, at worst this was a practical joke cooked up by those kids, more likely this was just a great deal of confusion.  (I still don't know who would rescue someone from a runaway balloon.  I guess if that happens your just screwed.)  

When I saw all of the coverage of this on my computer yesterday I heard the word wierd, eccentric, strange, odd, crazy, and colorful applied to the Heene's.  What did they do that was so strange?  They were actively interested in science.  They were interested in the UFO phenomena and held the belief that we are all descended from aliens.  They built this balloon in their back yard to do an experiment.  They made youtube video's as a family instead of alone in a room just talking....  Last but not least horror of horrors the dad said on TV to day they don't even have cable!!!  Call DCFS quick!  I have even heard some suggest that Mr. Heene beats his wife, based on the children fidgeting. (The AP has actually pursued this angle.  I guess they have never seen children who have ant's in their pants.) 


Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy


This all lead me to think how does one raise a scientist, engineer, or astronaut? If I had a child how could I interest them in science and learning and creativity instead of just name brands, gadgets, and consumerism?  Furthermore why should having minority beliefs, religious or secular make one a target for such a vile and vicious accusations as those mentioned above (wife beating).
 
Many of us had parents who were either science enthusiast, like the Heene's, or scientist. We had parents who did things with us, or at least watched PBS or the discovery channel with us. My father taught me about medicine and chemistry. He made polystyrene for me, and showed me a chemical reaction which will release hydrogen from water. What he didn't know about we watched tv shows about on PBS. I especially liked the subject of space travel and black holes back then. We also watched the news. Thanks to sundays (which I did not always like) spent watching "The McLaughlin Group" and "This week With David Brinkley" I learned to pay attention to politics. My mother taught me about biology and how to care for plants. They made me who I was, a kid interested in science and learning in general. Because to me science was not wrote recitation of trivial facts in a book. Science was for me, what it really is, an interactive real life experience.

That is hardly unusual and eccentric among scientist. I can think of a couple of people who had the same experience. One person I know had a father who was a pharmacist, he taught her about the various drugs and chemicals. She is a student at the university I am studying at now. Another person had a father who worked in the garment district of NYC who did much to interest his son in science. This man was Richard P. Feynmann.  He describes vividly how his strange odd father taught him about science, the difference between knowing something and knowing the name of something. (Cue to 3:49)


Lastly all of those who talk about how this guy must be abusive  the wife should leave and take the children...that's the story brewing for the next news cycle (unless some more sexy story comes up)... remember this story "Polygamist sect children reunited with happy parents 2 months after Texas' raid on compound" By MICHELLE ROBERTS , Associated Press,June 3, 2008   But those people are strange polygamist, they may therefore beat their wives, and have sex with their children.  (Ok so someone in Utah did that... but how many good protestant christians have too?)  What does this have to do with the space case Heene's they have strange beliefs therefore he must be a wife beater.  He cussed when that ballon flew away because he must be a wife beater.  How easy how easy would it be to apply that (il)logic to just about anyone?  How are scientist raised? They are raised by parents who engage with their children in the very way the Heene's do on some level. 
UPDATE: Apparently the sheriff responding to pressure from people calling him asked child protective services to get involved.  The moral of this story seems to be taking a really active family interest in science is tantamount to abuse.  I guess the Heene's should just get drunk like more normal parents. 


Comments

Gerhard Adam's picture
Unfortunately the guy hasn't done much to help his credibility.  While I agree that the abuse angle is a bit extreme, there's enough other information that suggests a healthy skepticism is in order.

Hank's picture
The guy doesn't interview very well but a lot of people who build homemade flying saucers in their backyard probably don't.   :)

No reason to think he was pulling a scam.  Or is a kook, much less abusive.   Some pretty talented people had eccentric parents.

Gerhard Adam's picture
All that's true.  What set my spider senses to tingling, was the realization that he was on the reality show "Wife Swap".  I agree completely with the idea that abuse is a tough sell, but reality shows suggest that, at some level, a desire for media attention exists. 

Apparently he also has several self-promoting YouTube videos, and there's a bit of a problem regarding why he called the news affiliate and the FAA before he called 911.

In and of itself, none of these are real evidence about a hoax, but my point is that there may be other issues that will draw far more scrutiny than the simple fact of being 'scientific' or even on the fringes.

Hfarmer's picture
I buy his explanation on not calling 911.  Consider that after the FAA told him to call 911...911 kept him on hold and called the FAA.  The only ones who did anything of note in the first 1/2 hour... the news copter which found the balloon and followed it's progress.
Basically all 911 emergency responders did was not search the house thoroughly and prepare to recover the boys remains from wherever he crashed.




Hfarmer's picture
To be honest I have seen more media insinuations than actual information.  
For example  "We did it for the show".  I saw the whole Wolf Blitzer interview.  Wolf was asking the police about a possible hoax, with the parents, and kids mics listening.  (Falcon "balloon boy" was not micd) Essentially calling them liars on national TV.

Blizer asked them to relay the questions to Falcon, "Where were you hiding?"  "Why didn't you come out".  That's when he said "you said....  We did it for the show".  

What does he mean we did it for the show...  I think he means earlier in the day he showed several media members where he was hiding and how he got up there.  That is what he means when he said "We did it for the show."  

In a situation like this the healthy scepticism falls on the claims the the accuser.  It remains to be proven that this was a hoax. 

My personal feeling is IF this was a hoax or prank... it was purpotrated by those boys.  Telling little brother to hide and we'll tell mom you flew away in the balloon.  Kids do that kind of thing you know.  



Stellare's picture
I'm sick to my stomach by how the media is torturing this poor family. Clearly they were scared to death by the idea of loosing one of their kids. How would any of us (non professional TV personalities or officials) come through on TV after such an experience? In fact even in one of our best moments most of us would not do all that well on TV.

Luckily my son is now an adult so he cannot be taken from me, but if people knew all the explosions and chemistry experiments I have performed with and for my son...I'll probably be in jail for life and never allowed to meet my kid again.

Scientists or plain curious people - just lock'em up, all of them!  And my all means, rescue the kids!

A woman's kitchen is a womans lab! :-)

Hfarmer's picture
Exactly!  
That's where were headed.  We have all seen the results from the "draw a scientist test".  The media describing Heene as a scientist probably helped do him in.  Consider what the average person thinks of scientist... and I don't just mean elementary school kids

They are making this guy out to be Dr. Frankenstein. 


Hfarmer's picture
This is what the sheriff has said... They are involving child protective services. 

"Alderden told CNN's Wolf Blitzer on Friday that, based on reports that the parents "took these children into potentially dangerous situations" with tornado chases, the experimental balloons and other activities, it would be "appropriate to involve child protection [services] to at least see what the family situation is and whether the children are in a safe condition."

Oh yes people who do scientific experiments and involve their children are dangerous kooks. :-/


Gerhard Adam's picture
In that I have to agree with you.  Regardless of whether his activities with his children were dangerous or not, they are his perogative as a parent and don't need the state's involvement.  Abuse and malicious intent is one thing, but the state should never get involved simply because some individuals feel certain activities are dangerous.

Hfarmer's picture
Honestly nothing he has done is more dangerous thank hunting.  No doubt there are people in TV land (This sherif is reacting to pressure, from people, who don't live there, calling his office) who would think that was abusive too. 

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <sup> <sub> <a> <em> <strong> <center> <cite> <code> <TH><ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p> <blockquote> <strike> <object> <param> <embed> <del> <pre> <b> <i> <table> <tbody> <div> <tr> <td> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <iframe>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
CAPTCHA
If you register, you will never be bothered to prove you are human again. And you get a real editor toolbar to use instead of this HTML thing that wards off spam bots.