Research into tobacco dependence published online today (Friday 17 October 2008) in the November issue of Addiction, has shown that recent ex-smokers who find exposure to other people's cigarette smoke pleasant are not any more likely to relapse than those who find it unpleasant.
Led by Dr Hayden McRobbie and Professor Peter Hajek of the Tobacco Dependence Research Unit at Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry, researchers examined the hypothesis that those who find the smell of smoke pleasant are more likely to relapse than those who have a neutral or negative reaction to it. Surprisingly, they concluded that finding the smell of other people's cigarettes pleasant does not make abstaining smokers any more likely to relapse.
The researchers studied a group of over a thousand smokers receiving smoking cessation treatment at the East London Smokers Clinic. During their six weeks of treatment (two weeks prior to quitting and four weeks afterwards) the smokers completed a weekly questionnaire that measured the severity of their withdrawal discomfort, and also asked them to rate how pleasant they found the smell of other people's cigarettes during the past week.
The results showed that during their first week of abstinence, 23 per cent of respondents found the smell of other people's cigarette smoke pleasant. Finding the cigarette smoke pleasant was not related to smoking status in the following week.
Lead author Dr Hayden McRobbie says, "Recent quitters can be reassured that finding the smell of cigarette smoke pleasant is not likely to lead them back to smoking."
Comments
On the other hand, even that is not really adequate when it comes down to walking across a busy street at night, filled with bars, pubs and clubs (hence many smokers standing outside) and I fully support the creation of well ventilated, interior smoking areas in public buildings and businesses. Mindless ostracization of smokers is counterproductive for everyone, but a hermetically sealed, interior smoking area with air filters, might well serve public health much more effectively. This is something of the equivalent of a "safe injection site" for heroin users, and will probably prove itself given proper study.
C. Waters (not verified) | 04/16/09 | 15:18 PM
Lila (not verified) | 05/22/09 | 13:24 PM









Is it actually somehow more bothersome for people that used to smoke, or are they secretly trying to eliminate temptation?